Healthcare Tech

Is human health coaching superior to AI for wellness programs? Navigating the Pros and Cons

Artificial Intelligence (AI) is gaining prominence in the health benefits industry. In an effort to stay relevant and profitable, wellness companies are increasingly adopting AI to replace human health coaching. While AI introduces innovation and efficiency, the question arises: Are human coaches essential for achieving long-term positive health outcomes? Let’s investigate the advantages and disadvantages of both approaches, exploring why a preference for human coaching might be crucial for sustainable wellness.


Pros of AI:

  • Efficiency and Accessibility: AI showcases efficiency and accessibility, providing immediate 24/7 access to information and solutions through bot-driven health coaching.
  • Scalability: The capacity to guide large populations simultaneously ensures comprehensive support for employees in large companies, even with significant numbers.
  • Cost-Effectiveness: The absence of a one-to-one coach-member relationship makes AI highly cost-effective for wellness programs.
  • Data Analysis: Advanced technology can analyze vast data sets, tailoring next steps for each member based on individual metrics and goals.
  • Consistency: Technology-driven communication eliminates human factors, ensuring heightened consistency in wellness programs.


Cons of AI:

  • Emotional Intelligence: AI lacks the emotional intelligence required to comprehend and address the intricate emotional and mental facets of an individual’s well-being.
  • Limited Scope: Research highlights that AI may only address a partial spectrum of issues, especially in the interconnected realms of physical and mental health.
  • Rigid Data Processing: AI’s rigid data processing may overlook rapidly changing circumstances or communication gaps, potentially impacting the effectiveness of wellness programs.
  • Personal Preference for Human Coaching: A significant 86% of individuals express a preference for human coaching over AI, recognizing the current limitations in the emotional realm. People want to speak to people.



Pros of Human Health Coaching:

  • Profound Connection: Human coaching establishes a profound level of connection, providing an invaluable personal touch to wellness programs.
  • Emotional Support and Empathy: Coaches offer emotional support and empathy, addressing mental health, stress, and deep issues.
  • Tailored Strategies: The ability to tailor strategies based on individual lifestyle, preferences, and evolving needs enhances the effectiveness of behavior adaptation.
  • Empowerment for Lasting Changes: Human coaches empower individuals beyond form completion or simple encouragement, fostering lasting behavioral changes.
  • Trust Building: Trust plays a pivotal role, creating an environment where individuals feel comfortable sharing personal challenges and working towards improvement.
  • Holistic Approach: Successful coaching, according to Rutjes, goes beyond goal achievement, encompassing relationship-building, implicit adaptation, and motivation cultivation.


Cons of Human Health Coaching:

  • Costly Investment: Human resources for coaching are a costly investment, especially with an increasing number of program members.
  • Need for Additional Coaches: As the program expands, there’s a proportional need to hire additional coaches to accommodate the growing number of participants.
  • Resource Intensive Training: Substantial time and resources are required to train coaches to meet the standard of care, adding to the financial commitment.
  • Inconsistency Challenges: Inherent diversity among humans, including varied backgrounds, coaching styles, linguistics, and personal circumstances, introduces challenges of inconsistency in coaching approaches.Bottom of Form


While AI health coaching offers clear benefits in accessibility and data processing, the irreplaceable element of the human touch persists in the wellness domain. The capacity to forge authentic connections, deliver emotional support, and tailor strategies to individual needs establishes human health coaching as the preferred avenue for fostering enduring well-being. Ultimately, the synergy between technology and the human touch emerges as the crucial factor unlocking transformative journeys to wellness.


HealthFleet, and its suite of wellness programs pioneers a harmonious blend of AI and dedicated human health coaching for both efficiency and personalization. In a departure from the standard AI-driven member outreach, HealthFleet leverages AI to empower their coaches. The platform strategically notifies coaches for outreach, enabling them to deliver tailored coaching to numerous members, cultivating an experience that feels exceptionally personal. The outcomes are noteworthy: an outstanding 80% engagement at the 12-month milestone, substantial healthcare cost savings amounting to $2,700 per member per year, 80% of members successfully reversing one or more metabolic factors, and an impressive 6% average weight loss.



Upcoming Events


Related Articles